My coauthor and I disagree about what a chapter is supposed to accomplish. Should we ask AI to merge our versions?
Resolve the chapter's purpose before asking AI to merge the prose. A fluent combination can conceal the disagreement while preserving both versions' competing priorities. You may end up with a longer chapter that still has no clear job.
Have each coauthor independently state the reader's starting question, the chapter's central claim, and what the reader should understand or be able to do at the end. Compare those statements before discussing favorite passages.
If the intended outcomes differ, decide whether one supports the other or whether they require separate chapters. If the outcomes match but the approaches differ, compare the versions against a shared brief:
- Which sequence makes the reasoning easiest to follow?
- Which examples directly support the central claim?
- What knowledge does each version assume?
- What essential material is missing from either version?
Use AI as a collaborative coeditor at this stage. Ask it to map the two arguments, identify duplication, and propose alternative structures with explicit tradeoffs. Redirect it when it mistakes a substantive disagreement for a wording problem.
Agree who has final editorial authority when consensus is unavailable. Then build a structural outline and test it on a short section before merging the full chapter.
Preserve meaningful disagreement when it benefits the reader. A clearly presented difference in judgment can be more useful than artificial consensus, provided the chapter explains the conditions behind each position and gives the reader a usable conclusion.
Category: Developmental editing